Episode Details

While some church power struggles stem from bad actors, a more common cause is blurred lines. In this episode, Thom and Sam tackle one of the most common sources of church dysfunction: confusion between what the board should do and what the staff should do.

1. 1. The term “board” could refer to an elder board, church council, deacons, or lay leadership. The point here is not ecclesiology but rather how a church operates functionally.
   2. When boards drift into operations or staff drift into governance, frustration follows. But when roles are clear, trust increases, decisions accelerate, and the mission stays front and center.
   3. We use “board member” and “trustee” synonymously, but there are some technical distinctions. Trustees have more legal and fiduciary responsibilities. Board members tend to have more spiritual governance and directional leadership.
   4. A single governing board composed solely of non-members is a warning sign.
   5. Most dysfunction comes from role confusion. Boards govern and guard; staff lead and execute.
   6. Before budgets and policies, board members must live lives worth imitating. Character precedes competency.
   7. Encouragement and accountability go together. Healthy boards don’t just “check” the Lead Pastor—they actively support, pray for, and strengthen them.
   8. Boards protect mission and vision, not manage ministry. Strategy execution belongs to the staff. Major shifts in direction are the board’s responsibility.
   9. Boards handle big decisions, not daily details. Annual budgets, land, and facilities are board responsibilities; operations are not.
   10. One point of accountability. Only the senior pastor should report to the board. Everyone else reports to the pastor. This keeps leadership clean and prevents internal politics.

Resources:

• Brown Church Development Group

• Upward Running

• Upward Sports

• “When God Builds a Church” by Bob Russell (affiliate link)

• “Who Is in Charge?” by Brad Waggoner (affiliate link)

• Church Equip

• The Hope Initiative

• Church Answers Platinum Membership

• Listen Now