Episode Details
Back to Episodes
Episode 76: David's Food Favorites — San Pedro & Caye Caulker
Description
Episode 76: David's Food Favorites — San Pedro & Caye Caulker
Food is a huge part of the Belize experience, and after 16+ years here, I've eaten my way across this country. Let me share what I've found on the islands.
San Pedro Go-To Spots
For Seafood (Note: I'm allergic to all seafood, but for my listeners):
- Elvi's, El Fogon, Caramba — You can't beat anything these places serve. Fresh catch, perfectly prepared. Expect $20-$40 for a full meal.
For Casual Lunch:
- Lily's Treasure Chest — On the beach in town, where a lot of locals go. Stew chicken with rice and beans is my go-to. $11 gets you stew chicken, rice and beans, and salad.
- Caliente — My favorite is the beef fajitas, $14.
For a Nicer Dinner:
- Blue Water Grill — Great atmosphere, right on the water. The steak and yucca is worth the splurge (~$43). Great seafood and sushi too.
Street Food in San Pedro
- Kevin's BBQ (between Super Buy South and the gas station) — Quarter chicken, rice and beans or beans and tortilla, salad for $7 USD.
- Pop-up in Caribbean Chicken parking lot (at night, in the south) — Amazing Mexican-type tacos, $6 USD for four tacos.
- Nary's Tacos — One of the best breakfast tacos on the island. Three tacos for 50 cents, or 37 cents for a pork taco. Full breakfast or stuffed fry jack available.
Tourist Traps to Avoid
Some resort places charge double for the same food you can get a block away. My rule: If it's a branded hotel and empty of locals, keep walking. If you see Belizeans, expats, and locals eating there, you're in the right place.
Caye Caulker
Smaller, more laid-back, and the food scene reflects that.
- Chef Juan's Kitchen and Pastries — Tacos are awesome. Simple spot, amazing food. Must try the Key lime pie.
- Las Palapas Belize — For lobster (when in season). Grilled, garlic butter, the works. $30-$60 depending on size.
- Erolyn's House of Fry Jacks — Selling barbecue ribs. A few dollars and you're set.
Lobster Season
June 15th to sometime between February 14th - March 1st. Outside those dates, it's illegal to catch or sell lobster. If someone offers you lobster in April, walk away. Respect the season — it's why Belize still has lobster.
Drink Pairings
- Belikin beer — With anything fried or grilled. Light, crisp, pairs with everything.
- Belikin Stout — Try it with ceviche (sounds weird, but it works).
- Rum punch at sunset — Toast in San Pedro makes a strong one, be warned.
- Fresh watermelon juice or lime juice — If you're not drinking. The fresh juices here are unreal.
- Coke Zero or frozen mojito — My personal drinks of choice.
Price Expectations on the Islands
- Street food and local spots: $5-8 USD
- Casual restaurants: $12-20 USD for a full meal
- Nice dinner with drinks: $40-60 USD per person
- High-end splurge: $80-100+ USD
The islands are more expensive than the mainland, but you can still eat well on a budget if you know where to go.
Myth of the Week
"You have to spend a lot to eat well on Ambergris Caye."
Not true. Some of my best meals have been $10 or less at local spots. The key is getting off the main tourist drag and asking locals, "Where do you eat?"
Tips for First-Time Visitors
- Cash is helpful — Some smaller spots don't take cards.
- Ask what's fresh
Listen Now
Love PodBriefly?
If you like Podbriefly.com, please consider donating to support the ongoing development.
Support Us