Episode Details
Back to Episodes
Weekly Roundup: Trump, Vance, and Just War Theory + Pete Pulp Fiction
Description
Religion scholars Brad Onishi and Dan Miller recap a week of conflict in which Pope Leo criticized war and bombing in a statement widely read as aimed at the U.S. approach to Iran, prompting a lengthy Trump Truth Social attack and backlash over an AI image of Trump as Jesus. JD Vance and Speaker Mike Johnson told the Pope to “stay in his lane” and invoked just war theory, leading Miller to explain its criteria and argue the Iran conflict fails them; the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops issued a response defending the Pope’s teaching authority and the church’s just war tradition. The hosts frame the dispute as exposing fissures within MAGA Christian nationalism, discuss claims of nationalism turning the nation and leader into God, and analyze Pete Hegseth’s rhetoric and prayer language as further evidence, alongside GOP figures and media urging the Pope to avoid politics while promoting religion in government.
00:00 Pope Versus Trump
01:07 Why Religion Matters
02:03 Iran War And Distraction
03:22 Papal Statement And Trump Blowup
04:16 AI Jesus Backlash
06:37 JD Vance Enters Fight
09:00 Pope Warns War Profiteers
10:14 Mike Johnson Just War Spin
11:53 Just War Theory Explained
15:58 Bishops Rebuke Vance
18:39 Fissures In Christian Nationalism
21:25 Aquinas And War As Evil
27:14 MAGA Splits And Catholic Voters
29:22 Vance Authority Christianity
32:32 Power Theology And Nationalism
35:33 Vance Versus Just War
37:07 Hegseth Pulp Prayer
38:57 Vengeance Voice Swap
44:35 TPUSA Flop Fallout
47:35 Trump As Messiah
52:27 GOP Tells Pope Quiet
56:21 One Way Christian Nationalism
59:16 Who Counts As Christian
01:03:40 Task Force Irony
01:05:35 Reasons For Hope
01:08:40 Discord Hope Stories
01:08:55 Closing Hope Notes
Subscribe for $3.65: https://axismundi.supercast.com/
Subscribe to our free newsletter: https://swaj.substack.com/
Order American Caesar by Brad Onishi: https://static.macmillan.com/static/essentials/american-caesar-9781250427922/
Donate to SWAJ: https://axismundi.supercast.com/donations/new
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices