Episode Details
Back to Episodes
Episode 68: HOA Health — Is It Well-Run or Going Broke?
Description
Episode 68: HOA Health — Is It Well-Run or Going Broke?
I've seen beautiful condos become nightmares because of terrible HOAs. I've seen modest buildings become great investments because of excellent management. The HOA matters more than the view.
Why HOA Health Is So Important
Your HOA affects:
- Your monthly costs: HOA fees can be hundreds per month. Special assessments can be tens of thousands.
- Your property value: Well-maintained buildings appreciate. Neglected buildings depreciate.
- Your quality of life: Good management means things work. Bad management means constant problems.
- Your ability to rent: HOA rules determine if and how you can rent.
- Your ability to sell: A troubled HOA scares away buyers.
You're not just buying a unit — you're buying into a partnership with every other owner and the management structure.
What Makes a Healthy HOA
- Adequate reserve fund: Most important financial indicator. Should cover major repairs without special assessments. Funding at least 70% of recommended levels. (Grand Caribe in San Pedro is the gold standard.)
- Balanced budget: Income covers expenses, no chronic deficits.
- Low delinquency rate: Target less than 10%, under 5% is excellent.
- Professional management: Or highly competent volunteer board with proper systems.
- Regular maintenance: Common areas look good, systems work, repairs happen promptly.
- Transparent communication: Owners receive financial reports, meeting minutes, updates.
- Engaged but not contentious ownership: Owners care but aren't constantly fighting.
- Clear, reasonable rules: Written policies that make sense and are consistently enforced.
Warning Signs of a Troubled HOA
- Low or no reserves — special assessments are coming
- Frequent special assessments — not budgeting properly
- High delinquency — HOA can't pay its bills
- Deferred maintenance — if visible areas are neglected, what about hidden systems?
- Rising fees without improved services
- Contentious meetings — drama means dysfunction
- High turnover in management or board
- Unusual financial arrangements
- Refusal to share financials — what are they hiding?
- Lots of units for sale — owners are fleeing
Myth of the Week
"Low HOA fees mean a good deal."
Often the opposite. Low fees usually mean:
- Under-funded reserves: When the roof needs replacing, everyone gets a $15,000 special assessment.
- Deferred maintenance: Building deteriorates, values drop.
- Smaller building with fewer amenities: This is fine — fewer shared costs legitimately mean lower fees.
I'd rather pay $500/month to a well-funded HOA than $200/month to one that's going to hit me with a $20,000 assessment next year.
Financial Documents to Request
- Annual budget: Projected income/expenses, actual results comparison
- Balance sheet: Assets, liabilities, reserve fund balance, any debt
- Income and expense statement: Trends over multiple years
- Reserve study: Professional assessment of future repair needs
- Delinquency report: How many owners behind on fees?
- Meeting minutes: Issues being discussed, conflicts, pending decisions
- Insurance certificate: Coverage, limits, claims history
If the HOA won't provide these, that itself is a red flag.
Evaluating the Reserve Fund
- What'