Episode Details

Part two of the Mainline Murders picks up right where we left off: with the deeply unsettling inventory found in Susan Reinert's car, including a blue comb engraved with the 79th Reserve Command, the very same unit served by her own principal. Who was Dr. Jay Smith, really?

On paper, Principal Jay Smith was a decorated Army colonel, a man who'd carpooled with John Eisenhower and earned a doctorate. Behind that carefully curated image was a much darker story: a daughter lost to heroin addiction who vanished without a trace, a basement that read like a fever dream, a homemade gun range, and an arrest that earned him the nickname the Prince of Darkness.

But Dr. Smith is only part of the picture. This episode also takes a long, uncomfortable look at Bill Bradfield — English teacher, serial love-bomber, and the man who would become the unlikely thread connecting everything.

With five women in his orbit (yes, five), a failing arts-and-crafts store dragging him deep into debt, and a series of increasingly unhinged confessions to his young colleague about mafia hit lists and silencer demonstrations in broad daylight, Bill is spinning a web so elaborate it almost sounds like bad fiction. Almost. Because somewhere in the middle of all of it is Susan Reinert's name. And the clock is ticking.

"That's Genevieve. And that's Kaitlyn."

Sisters-in-law, best friends, former CNAs, and the sharp-witted duo behind Camping Is Canceled. Known for their mix of research-driven storytelling and unfiltered commentary, Gen and Kait tackle true crime cases (and paranormal rabbit holes) with empathy, curiosity, and a healthy dose of dark humor.

📲 Instagram: @campingiscanceled

📲 TikTok: @campingiscanceled

📧 Contact: campingiscanceled@gmail.com

🎧 Listen now — everywhere you get your podcasts.

New episodes drop every Friday. Want more stories, no ads, and exclusive bonus episodes every Thursday?Join our Patreon to support the show!