Episode Details

In this episode, we explore the messy fight for women s suffrage. So imagine you're organizing like the absolute biggest civil rights convention of your century. You draft your demands, you get all your allies together, and then your own co -organizers pull you aside and basically tell you that asking for the right to vote is just too ridiculous. Yeah, that it would make the whole movement look like a joke. Exactly. And that is exactly what happened to Elizabeth Cady Stanton in 1848. at the Seneca Falls Convention. It really is wild to think about. It is. The very spark that ignited the women's rights movement almost didn't even include suffrage because the women themselves thought it was too extreme. So welcome to this custom -tailored deep dive created specifically for you. Glad to be here. Today, we're pulling apart a really comprehensive historical text, specifically the Wikipedia article on women's suffrage in the United States. And it's a massive pivot. They look at the recently passed 14th Amendment, the one granting citizenship to all persons born or naturalized in the U .S., and they find what they think is a loophole. This is what becomes known as the New Departure Strategy. The legal logic of the New Departure was actually quite brilliant. Walk us through it. Well, the suffragists argued that since the 14th Amendment made them citizens, and since voting is an inherent privilege of citizenship, they already had the right to vote. Oh, I see. Yeah, they argued they didn't need a new law at all. They just needed to enforce the existing one. So they didn't wait around. They just started walking into polling places. Yes. Hundreds of women across the country trying to cast ballots. And Susan B. Anthony actually succeeds in voting in the 1872 presidential election. She does. And she is promptly arrested