Episode Details

Send us Fan Mail

In this chilling episode of Hidden Threads, Macky Outlaw and Jus thread through one of history's most depraved monsters: Albert Fish, the "Gray Man," "Werewolf of Wysteria," "Brooklyn Vampire," and true Boogeyman. Born in 1870, Fish was a seemingly mild-mannered painter and family man who hid unimaginable horrors—molesting hundreds of children, torturing and murdering at least three (likely more), and committing acts of cannibalism.

We break down his traumatic childhood in an abusive orphanage, the development of extreme paraphilias (including sadomasochism, pedophilia, coprophagia, and self-harm like embedding needles in his pelvis), the infamous 1928 abduction and murder of 10-year-old Grace Budd (lured with a fake birthday party ruse, then strangled, dismembered, and partially eaten), and the grotesque 1934 letter he sent to her family confessing the details. Fish confessed to other killings like Billy Gaffney (4) and Francis McDonnell (8), was convicted of Grace's murder, and executed in the electric chair at Sing Sing in 1936—reportedly thrilled by the "supreme thrill."

This isn't just a killer profile—we confront the sickness of pedophilia head-on: its roots in trauma, paraphilic disorders, why it drives such extreme violence in some, societal failures to protect children then and now, and the lasting psychological scars on victims and families. Trigger warning: Extremely gra

Support the show