Episode Details

Send us Fan Mail

There's a specific moment that defines CHRO careers — and it has nothing to do with strategy, credentials, or knowing your P&L. 

It's the moment when something important is heading the wrong direction in a senior room, and you have to decide what to do. You either swallow it and stay quiet, or you come in so hard that the room goes cold. And in both cases, the decision keeps moving without you. 

Most of the CHROs this happens to aren't lacking knowledge or confidence. They're losing influence because of how they challenge — not whether they challenge.

This episode is about the third path: challenging with curiosity. If you've ever been right in a room and still watched the decision go sideways, this one is for you.

What You'll Learn

• Why the gap between "knowing the answer" and "influencing the outcome" is behavioral, not analytical
• The four faulty assumptions that keep confident CHROs excluded from key decisions — including why directness and being right aren't the strategies you think they are
• A three-move framework — slow the certainty, name the data not the conclusion, seek what you might be missing — for challenging without triggering defensiveness
• Why asking questions is not soft: how precise inquiry surfaces the assumption underneath the metric while letting the other person own the insight
• A six-step weekly practice for building the "challenging with curiosity" muscle, from auditing your behavioral default to debriefing one challenge conversation per week
• The bridge phrases that signal inquiry without signaling uncertainty — and why they only work in your authentic voice

Key Quotes

• "If you don't challenge, you're not adding value. And if you challenge badly, you lose access."
• "Do you want to be right, or do you want to be effective? Directness is a delivery mode — it's not a strategy."
• "Silence isn't neutral. It's a choice. And 'later' is often never."
• "The skill that keeps CHROs in the room is the ability to raise a hard thing in a way that opens the conversation rather than closes it."

Sources for Statistics Cited

• 89% of CEOs believe their CHROs should have a central role in driving long-term growth — Accenture, "The CHRO as a Growth Executive" (2023)
• Only 45% of those same CEOs are creating the conditions to let the CHRO have that impact — Accenture, "The CHRO as a Growth Executive" (2023)
• New hires enter feeling optimistic, then over time feel less safe speaking up — Edmondson, Bransby & Kerrissey, HBR (July 2024)
• 93% of executives report the highest level of psychological safety — Wiley Workplace Intelligence, 2023
• 76% of executives say they feel safe taking interpersonal risk — Wiley Workplace Intelligence, 2023
• 50% of employees believe their ideas will not be taken seriously — Courageous Cultures, via Fast Company (July 2020)

Support the show

If this episode landed, the next move is yours. 

Coaching is where it closes fastest — Jackson has developed CHROs from both sides of the table, as their leader and as their coach. The CHRO Ascent Academy, CHRO Chronicles, and the best-selling Substack are there too. 

All at mytalentsherpa.com.

In private equity: Propulsion AI surfaces workforce risk before the close and translates strategy into individual accountability after it. Before AI automation -  drive outcome clarity with digital teammates to do the work fast and at scale. 

All at getpropulsion.ai.