Episode Details

It’s Season 1, Episode 4, and the "plain life" is getting scandalous. The snark squad is reeling after Esmeralda’s "spiritual breakthrough," which was really just a tearful goodbye to her fake lashes and acrylic nails. While she surrendered her "armor," Billie Jo endured a painfully awkward cornfield date with Jacob—a man who only says "okay" but hides a secret stash of tattoos and nipple piercings under his Sunday best. The drama hit a fever pitch with Matt’s return, causing Kendra to literally crawl to him while an axe-wielding James simmered with jealousy. Between the hidden body mods and the threat of pioneer-style violence, this episode proved that "plain" people have the messiest secrets.