Podcast Episode Details
Back to Podcast Episodes
New Arguments Against Caring About Fertility Collapse From Philosophy Tube
In this episode, Malcolm and Simone Collins dive deep into the recent Philosophy Tube video on demographic collapse and falling fertility rates. They critically analyze the arguments presented, discuss the broader implications for society, and explore the political, economic, and cultural factors influencing birth rates across the world.
The conversation covers:
* The differences in fertility rates between conservatives and progressives, and how these trends are accelerating.
* A critique of Philosophy Tube’s approach, including the use of dramatization and political statements.
* The impact of demographic changes on economies, with a focus on Japan and other developed countries.
* The role of nationalism, technological advancement, and cultural attitudes in shaping population trends.
* Misconceptions about the causes of declining birth rates, including the roles of women in the workforce and economic factors.
* The influence of ideology, media, and policy on public perceptions of demographic issues.
* A discussion of the “mind virus” concept and how cultural and biological factors may interact in shaping societal trends.
Malcolm and Simone also reflect on their own approach to research, fact-checking, and the importance of honest debate. The episode is a mix of critical analysis, personal anecdotes, and thought-provoking commentary on one of the most pressing issues facing modern societies.
If you enjoy in-depth discussions on culture, politics, and demographics, make sure to subscribe and join the conversation in the comments!
[00:00:00]
Malcolm Collins: Hello Simone. We are gonna talk about a number of things on this podcast. One of the first we’re gonna go into is going to be Philosophy Tube. Oh, the famous trans YouTuber did a big piece on why falling fertility rates aren’t actually an issue at all, and watching her. Felt like being spoken down to by an hour from somebody from the Capitol in the Hunger Games.
But I am in one of the districts
Now before we begin, we have a very special film brought to you all the way from the capitol.
Speaker 4: Fewer babies, aging populations. The strain on the economy as humankind collides with nature, it’s all overblown. A moral panic that was had by previous generations whose mistakes we are repeating.
Malcolm Collins: The thing is also like. In America if you are a teenager and you have Republican parents, and keep in mind like teenagers are not even that Republican, you have an 81% chance of being Republican.
[00:01:00] Yeah. If you have democratic parents, it’s a 89% chance of being democratic. Mm-hmm. Well, what this means unfortunately for her is she is preaching to her audience to basically sterilize a community that it only benefits us that is being sterilized.
But another trend we’re going to talk about is this difference in, in conservative and progressive fertility rates is actually increasing and the speed at which it’s increasing is speeding up.
Oh, really? People like her. But as a side note here, despite me appreciating what she did.
Like Simone, you tried to watch it too, right? Like it was bad.
Speaker 3: What you’ve just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point. In your rambling, incoherent response, were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought? Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. May [00:02:00] God have mercy on your soul.
Simone Collins: watched the whole thing from start to finish and could not, I must had, before I met you, I would’ve assumed that it was because I was too dumb and I couldn’t follow the argument.
Having now met you and, and gained a little bit more self-respect, I think a lot of it was broadly incoherent. It, it ends with her, a tran
Published on 1 month, 1 week ago