Episode Details

The Donna Adelson appeal is now underway after her defense team officially filed a notice of appeal following her murder conviction, marking a major new chapter in one of the most talked-about cases in true crime news. In this episode, we break down what the Donna Adelson appeal means legally, what arguments the defense may raise, and how prosecutors are expected to respond as the case moves into the appellate phase.

We explain the conviction timeline, the legal grounds commonly used in appeals, and whether procedural errors, jury decisions, or evidentiary disputes could impact the outcome of the Donna Adelson appeal. The discussion also looks at how appellate courts review murder convictions and what this process could mean for the future of the Adelson case.

Through real crime stories and survivor stories, the STS podcast explores how appeals reshape high-profile cases and why some convictions are upheld while others are challenged years later. We also examine lingering cold cases questions connected to the broader investigation and what listeners should watch for next.

Key Points Covered:

Defense files notice of appeal after conviction

Breakdown of the appellate process

Possible legal arguments from the defense

Prosecutors’ likely response strategy

Timeline of the Adelson case leading to conviction

What happens next in appellate court

Impact on ongoing true crime news coverage

Welcome to Surviving The Survivor, the show that brings you the #Bestguests in all of #truecrime. In this STS episode, Emmy Award–Winning Journalist Joel Waldman is joined by #BestGuests as they break down Donna’s latest move—why she believes she didn’t get a fair trial, and what this could mean for the Adelson family moving forward. Or is this just another desperate attempt to avoid justice for Dan Markel or are there grounds for an appeal? 

STS continues to follow this case as family, friends and the community keep hoping for more #justicefordanmarkel

#BestGuests include: 

Dave Aronberg, Former Palm Beach County State Attorney and State Senator 

Jo Potuto, Law Professor 

Neama Rahmani, Trial Lawyer

Support the show & be a part of #STSNation:

Donate to STS' Trial Travel: Https://www.paypal.com/ncp/payment/GJ...

VENMO: @STSPodcast or Https://www.venmo.com/stspodcast

Check out STS Merch:

Listen Now