Episode Details

Nonprofit leaders love to default to newsletters - long, clunky, “Fall Update”-style emails stuffed with program blurbs, raffle announcements, and event reminders. But newsletters don’t raise money. In fact, they train donors to skim, ignore, or unsubscribe. In this episode, I break down why newsletters flop, what you should be sending instead, and how shifting to single-topic, story-driven campaigns can multiply your revenue without adding more work. You’ll learn how to replace the newsletter grind with an email system that actually sparks giving, builds donor trust, and scales with you.

Topics:

• Why traditional newsletters train donors to tune you out
• The psychology of distraction and why donors need focus, not info dumps
• Story-driven, single-topic emails that lead to action (instead of updates no one reads)
• How to send more emails without donor fatigue
• The role of email as a scalable, foundational fundraising engine
• A step-by-step alternative to newsletters: campaign-style email sequences

For a full list of links and resources mentioned in this episode, click here.

Bloomerang is the complete donor, volunteer, and fundraising management solution that helps thousands of nonprofits like yours. Book your demo here. Read The 2026 Giving Signals Report here. 

Resources:

• Easy Emails For Impact™: The $5K+ Fundraising Campaign System
• Purpose & Profit Club® Fundraising + Marketing Accelerator   
• The SPRINT Method™: Your shortcut to 10K fundraisers 
• Instagram, LinkedIn, website , weekly newsletter  
• [FREE] The Brave Fundraiser’s Guide: Stop getting ignored. Start raising more.
  
  May contain affiliate links