Episode Details

Back to Episodes

Pull Five Reviews and Try to Rank Them. If the CHRO Can't, HR Talent Reviews Are Theater

Season 2025 Episode 63 Published 1 year, 2 months ago
Description

Everyone hates the annual review, but what if the part you're about to throw out is the part that works?

Once-a-year feedback is too late to change anything and too rare to build trust. The fashionable fix is scrapping ratings, but companies that tried it mostly went back. Ratings are how you reward high performers and keep the system honest. The real problem is the calendar, and reviews so vague nobody can tell the best from the rest.

In this episode, Jackson and Scott break down how to move to real-time coaching while keeping the standards ratings provide.

You'll discover:

  • Why once-a-year feedback is both too late and too rare to change behavior
  • Why scrapping ratings is the wrong fix and what breaks when you do it
  • How to build continuous coaching modeled on serious sports teams

If you're being pushed to drop performance ratings, listen now and learn what to fix first.

Music by AudioCoffee: https://www.audiocoffee.net/

Powered by Talent Sherpa

The Consequential CHRO is the business-first HR leadership podcast for Chief People Officers and HR executives who want to learn what CEOs want from HR and become the Chief of Work, owning talent strategy, performance management, succession planning, job architecture, and AI and work design so the CHRO and CEO build the business together.

We publish Monday and Thursday mornings at 7AM Eastern. Don't forget to subscribe and we'd appreciate a review. 


Talent Sherpa: https://mytalentsherpa.com

Propulsion AI: https://getpropulsion.ai

Music by AudioCoffee: https://www.audiocoffee.net/


Thank you for sharing your scarce time with us. Keep climbing!

Listen Now

Love PodBriefly?

If you like Podbriefly.com, please consider donating to support the ongoing development.

Support Us