Podcast Episode Details
Back to Podcast Episodes
HOW BANKS INDIVIDUALLY CREATE MONEY OUT OF NOTHING: Secrets of Money Creation Revealed - Richard A. Werner (2014)
HOW BANKS INDIVIDUALLY CREATE MONEY OUT OF NOTHING: Unveiling the Magic How Banks Create Money Out of Thin Air - Richard A. Werner (2014).
"Can banks individually create money out of nothing? — The theories and the empirical evidence" by Richard A. Werner (2014).
Welcome to another episode of "The Secrets of Success," where we uncover the hidden mechanisms that shape our world and reveal the groundbreaking insights that can redefine how we think about success—both personal and economic.
Today, we’re diving into a fascinating and somewhat mind-bending paper titled "Can banks individually create money out of nothing? — The theories and the empirical evidence" by Richard A. Werner, published in the International Review of Financial Analysis and available at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1057521914001070. Released under a Creative Commons license as open access, this study, conducted around the time of the 2008 banking crisis, offers the first empirical proof that banks can conjure money out of thin air—a concept that sounds like magic but has profound implications for how we understand wealth, power, and success in the modern economy. So, grab a coffee, settle in, and let’s explore this financial wizardry together!
The story begins with a question that’s been debated by economists for centuries: do banks merely shuffle money around, or do they have the power to create it? This debate gained urgency after the 2008 financial meltdown, which exposed the fragility of our banking systems and sparked a renewed curiosity about how money really works. Richard Werner, an economist with a knack for challenging the status quo, steps into this fray with a bold experiment. His paper isn’t just theoretical musing—it’s a detective story, complete with a real-world test that turns economic theory on its head. Published and accessible to all thanks to its open-access status, Werner’s work invites us to rethink the foundations of success in a world where money isn’t just earned but, in some cases, seemingly invented.
Werner introduces us to three competing ideas about banking. First, there’s the financial intermediation theory, which paints banks as middlemen, collecting deposits from savers and lending them to borrowers—like a financial matchmaker with no real creative power. Then there’s the fractional reserve theory, which suggests that while individual banks don’t create money, the system as a whole does, thanks to a clever trick where banks keep only a fraction of deposits as reserves, allowing loans to spawn new deposits across the network. Finally, the credit creation theory argues that each bank can independently whip up money from nothing every time it issues a loan. This last idea is the wild card, suggesting that banks hold a kind of alchemical power over our economy. Werner’s mission? To figure out which of these theories holds water—and the stakes couldn’t be higher for understanding how success is built in our financial systems.
What makes this paper a standout is Werner’s decision to move beyond speculation and into the field. He teamed up with Raiffeisenbank Wildenberg e.G., a cooperative bank in Germany, and its director, Marco Rebl, who opened the doors to the bank’s inner workings. The experiment was simple yet ingenious: Werner borrowed money from the bank while closely monitoring its internal records to see where the funds came from. Was the money pulled from existing deposits or reserves, or did it materialize out of nowhere? This real-time sleuthing allowed Werner to catch the money creation process in action, turning a theoretical debate into a tangible revelation.
The results? Pure financial magic. Werner discovered that when the bank issued the loan, the money didn’t come from any pre-ex
Published on 4 weeks, 1 day ago