Episode Details

Dr. Joe Rigney is a Fellow of Theology at New Saint Andrews College. In his controversial bestselling book "The Sin of Empathy" (Canon Press) he argues that empathy becomes sinful when divorced from truth and biblical standards.

In our conversation, Dr. Rigney explains how weaponized empathy manipulates through emotional validation demands rather than genuine care. He describes how many Christians have internalized a "progressive gaze" that judges their faithfulness by secular approval rather than biblical standards.

The episode explores practical alternatives to toxic empathy, including Christ-centered compassion that stays anchored to truth while genuinely caring for hurting people.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

1. Empathy becomes sinful when untethered from truth and biblical standards of compassion.
2. Weaponized empathy manipulates through emotional blackmail, demanding validation over truth-seeking.
3. Christians must resist the progressive gaze that judges faithfulness by secular approval.
4. True compassion involves staying anchored to reality while helping those who suffer.
5. Playing the victim differs from being a victim - Christ suffered without self-pity.
6. Good pretending means acting as your Spirit-filled self would in difficult situations.

CONNECT WITH DR. RIGNEY

• "The Sin of Empathy" - https://a.co/d/fKGbwti
• "Leadership and Emotional Sabotage" - https://a.co/d/9C2obRX
• "Live Like a Narnian" - https://a.co/d/bFfV1rD
• "Lewis on the Christian Life" - https://a.co/d/bKPdHea
• https://canonplus.com/ - use code WADE for $0.99 first month

MENTIONED IN THIS EPISODE

• "A Failure of Nerve" by Edwin Friedman - https://a.co/d/iOlbrzf
• "Against Empathy" by Paul Bloom - https://a.co/d/2gTyntc
• "Toxic Empathy" by Allie Beth Stuckey - https://a.co/d/2gTyntc
• "Shepherds for Sale" by Meg Basham - https://a.co/d/aD7uiLy

The Will Spencer Podcast was formerly known as "The Renaissance of Men."

EXITING THE NEW AGE COURSE

I spent twenty years in the New Age. This is what I learned on the way out.

13 chapters, study guide, practices inventory, 30+ book bibliography.

A new section on Christian apologetics to the New Age is in production. Buy now at $29 and get the upgrade free when the price goes to $49.

https://willspencer.co/exit

MENTORSHIP FOR MEN

I mentor men one-on-one through 12 weeks of biblical mentorship, with daily accountability.

If you've built something real but you're stuck at a transition that competence alone can't solve, book a free clarity call:

https://willspencer.co/mentorship

CONNECT

• YouTube
• Twitter/X
• Substack
• Instagram