Episode Details
Back to EpisodesI Mistook Polish for Depth. My Worst Executive Hire and the HR Assessment the CHRO Trusted
Description
What if the candidate fooling you is also fooling themselves?
The worst hire is often not a liar. It's someone who believes their own story, aces your assessments and still can't do the job. Jackson hired a number two optimized for one demanding CEO relationship, and every tool agreed. He mistook polish for depth and confidence for insight. Assessments are tools, not truths. Trust your instincts alongside the tools, and verify.
In this episode, Jackson breaks down the hire that taught him how self-deception slips past even good hiring systems.
You'll discover:
- Why optimizing a hire for one relationship can backfire
- How to screen for genuine curiosity instead of polish
- What to do early when what you see stops matching what you were promised
If you've ever trusted a perfect assessment and regretted it, listen now and learn what to look for next time.
Music by AudioCoffee: https://www.audiocoffee.net/
Powered by Talent Sherpa
The Consequential CHRO is the business-first HR leadership podcast for Chief People Officers and HR executives who want to learn what CEOs want from HR and become the Chief of Work, owning talent strategy, performance management, succession planning, job architecture, and AI and work design so the CHRO and CEO build the business together.
We publish Monday and Thursday mornings at 7AM Eastern. Don't forget to subscribe and we'd appreciate a review.
Talent Sherpa: https://mytalentsherpa.com
Propulsion AI: https://getpropulsion.ai
Music by AudioCoffee: https://www.audiocoffee.net/
Thank you for sharing your scarce time with us. Keep climbing!