Episode Details

When your world's on fire, the schedule's in chaos, and the goblins are unionizing—welcome to West Marches.

In this episode, the hosts venture deep into the untamed wilds of West Marches–style tabletop roleplaying games. With no regular party, no fixed storyline, and no safety net, they explore how this classic format redefines player agency and opens the door to truly dynamic storytelling. The hosts explain how to build a vibrant, reactive world filled with tension, consequence, and creative freedom.

They also share tips for managing the behind-the-scenes chaos: prepping seasonal events, tracking a living timeline, and handling player-driven schedules without losing your mind. Along the way, they touch on the mechanical differences between Pathfinder 2 and D&D 5e in supporting exploration-based gameplay and share some clever ideas for managing treasure, experience gaps, and inevitable player death.

Links

• Hexploration on Archives of Nethys
• Mork Borg (affiliate link)
• Outdoor Survival
• PF2 GM Core (affiliate link)
• Shadowdark
• RPGBOT.Podcast Episodes
  • Random Encounters

If you want to get into a West Marches Campaign and join his personal Discord Server, contact Ash Ely at BlueSky: @GravenAshes

• West Marches games emphasize flexible scheduling and nonlinear, player-driven adventures.
• The world is sandbox-style—no set party or plot—and players choose when and where to explore.
• Hex crawling and random encounters enhance exploration and inject unpredictability.
• A successful West Marches world is reactive, with consequences shaped by player choices.
• GM prep includes world timelines, seasons, and milestone-based time management.
• NPCs may be unreliable, adding narrative tension and misdirection.
• The format suits drop-in/drop-out play, allowing varied player participation.
• Players must prepare before sessions, as they drive the story.

• The world should feel lived-in, with visible effects from past player actions.
• Incorporating pacing shifts and seasonal changes creates depth and realism.
• Building a sense of urgency can help motivate player decisions.
• Character death and level gaps must be handled carefully to maintain balance and satisfaction.
• Creative treasure systems can engage players more than traditional loot drops.

• Pathfinder 2 excels at structured exploration, making it a strong choice for West Marches.