Episode Details

On Mother’s Day, 1993, the Stabb family gathered at their parent’s rural home outside of Canastota, New York to honor their matriarch, Jessie. But the celebration was short-lived because less than 24 hours later, Jessie and Carl, her husband of almost 50 years, were found dead. As the couple spent the evening watching television together in the comfort of their home, they were both shot in the head by a killer who stood just outside their living room window. Who would have a motive to kill the Stabbs? A New York State police Investigator and family members share their insights on this perplexing case that has spanned more than 30 years.