Episode Details

Christians talk a lot about “backsliding,” that is, doubts or struggles with our faith. Often the stories we share reflect characters who do the same. But how can Christian-made stories best explore this challenge, moving past cliches and shallow pictures of “backsliders” and showing more realistic images of people who fall back from faith but find restoration in Jesus?

Concession stand

• We’ve already talked about “deconstructing” (episode 10). This isn’t that.
• We’ll also tread lightly on the challenge of whether Christians can “fall away.”
• Some of this overlaps with tropey fiction evangelism, worth its own episode.
• We’ll critique some shallow backsliding narratives, hopefully in good faith.
• Our purpose is positive: to point to better fictional examples of backsliding.

1. How to backslide badly in a Christian(?) book

First, we’ll consider a fictional example Stephen wrote in this older article.

Charis wanted to cry. Did Michael really mean it? Was he really saying there was a good God who loved everyone in the world — everyone, including her? But he could not mean that, she thought. After all, she was not important, beautiful, wealthy, or special. No one could love her after all the bad things she had done. Not even God.

• “Blind faith” is a safe trope, an evangelical version of “just believe in yourself.”
• It’s a pre-cleaned, saccharine version of the sufferings Christians do have.
• Not all backsliders have simple stories. “God loves you” doesn’t fix things.

Second, we’ll consider Mack from the preachy, kinda-Christian novel The Shack.

• The story tries to present tragedy honestly, but keeps Nerfing the horror.
• Three authors, one confusion: The Shack‘s fictional “trinity” is tropey.
• The shtick only works with bad assumptions about The Church Back Home.

2. If you’re going to become a backsliding book hero, do it right

Rayford Steele in the Left Behind series is actually a great example.

• Left Behind book 6, Assassins, brought Rayford to a crisis point.
• The story asked: Is it righteous to seek vengeance against the Antichrist?
• Book 7 then explored Rayford’s repentance and restoration by the Church.

Mary Magdalene’s character in The Cho