Episode Details

THE NICK SHURN MATTER

Broadcast: December 1955 Star: Bob Bailey Format: 5‑part serial (this summary reflects the full arc)

⭐ Episode Summary (Spoiler‑Safe)

A brutal Michigan blizzard sets the stage for one of Johnny Dollar's most atmospheric and physically demanding investigations. When a woman named Kathy O'Dare and her young daughter Jill disappear from their home in Bramberry, Michigan, the local sheriff fears they've been abducted by Benny Stark, a violent gunman with a long criminal history.

But Johnny Dollar isn't convinced. He believes Kathy fled voluntarily — terrified, armed, and heading into the deep woods she knows better than anyone. As the storm worsens, Johnny must race against time, weather, and a dangerous fugitive to find Kathy and Jill before the blizzard claims them.

The case becomes a tense wilderness chase involving abandoned cars, hidden cabins, and a confrontation in the snow that pushes Johnny to the edge of exhaustion. When he finally reaches Kathy, he uncovers the truth behind her flight — and the deadly chain of events that brought Benny Stark to her door.

⭐ Key Elements of the Story

• A Michigan blizzard that becomes a character in its own right

• A missing woman and child with a desperate reason for running

• A violent fugitive stalking the woods

• Johnny Dollar navigating snow‑choked trails, abandoned vehicles, and freezing darkness

• A tense cabin confrontation that reveals the truth

• A final showdown with Benny Stark that forces Johnny into a fight for survival

⭐ Why This Episode Works

This is one of the most visually vivid Johnny Dollar stories — a survival thriller wrapped inside an insurance investigation. Bob Bailey's performance captures the physical strain of battling the storm, the emotional stakes of protecting a mother and child, and the moral weight of confronting a dangerous man in the wilderness.

Listeners get:

• Strong suspense

• A harsh, wintry atmosphere

• A human story of fear, protection, and desperation

• A dramatic, satisfying resolution

It's a standout in the Bailey era for its pacing, tension, and cinematic feel.

⭐ Characters

• Johnny Dollar — Freelance insurance investigator

• Kathy O'Dare — Missing woman hiding from danger

• Jill O'Dare — Kathy's young daughter

• Benny Stark — Gunman with a violent past

• Mike — Friend of Kathy, emotionally invested in her safety

• Deputy Dan Martin — Local law enforcement assisting the search

⭐ Atmosphere

Snow. Darkness. Wind. Isolation. This is Johnny Dollar in one of his most physically grueling cases — a story where nature is as deadly as the gunman he's hunting.

⭐ Credits

Written and narrated by Jon Hagadorn Produced by 1001 Stories Network LLC Website: www.bestof1001stories.com

⭐ Support the Show

If you enjoy 1001 Radio Days and our continuing run of Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar, please leave a review and share the show. Your support keeps these classic radio dramas alive.

Get all of our shows at one website: WWW.BESTOF1001STORIES.COM

REVIEWS NEEDED . My email works as well for comments: 1001storiespodcast@gmail.com

SUPPORT OUR SHOW BY BECOMING A PATRON! https://.patreon.com/1001storiesnetwork. Its time I started asking for support! Thank you. Its a few dollars a month OR a one