Episode Details

Supernatural: Season 1, Episode 3, Dead in the Water recap 🌊 Berly and LA are back on Denim-wrapped Nightmares, a Supernatural rewatch podcast, and this week's cold open is a full-on Jaws homage (1975, not the '80s, thank you very much!). A girl gets pulled under Lake Manitoc, Wisconsin (fictional lake, though Manitowoc IS a real town, and yes, we mixed them up too), and the Winchester boys are on the case.

Sam and Dean roll into town posing as federal wildlife officers, armed with newspaper clippings, actual paper maps, and a complete inability to dress like any kind of officer. They meet Sheriff Jake Devins, his daughter Andrea (Amy Acker of Angel and Person of Interest), and her son Lucas, who hasn't spoken since watching his dad drown.

Dean bonds with Lucas over stick figure drawings (his artistic skills are... lacking), and the kid hands him a suspiciously good drawing of a house. When people start getting pulled under by black water in their own sinks and bathtubs, the boys realize they're dealing with the vengeful spirit of Peter Sweeney, a bullied kid who vanished 35 years ago.

Episode Highlights:

• Kicking things off with "Dead in the Water" sung to Smoke on the Water
• LA asking "When are they gonna take their shirts off?" (patience, girl!)
• A brief Marky Mark moment with Sam's tum-tum (blink and you'll miss it)
• Dean's tragic stick figure family portrait
• "Come play with me" giving major Shining vibes
• The creepy decayed arm grabbing Lucas
• Dean's parting wisdom to Lucas: "Zeppelin rules!"

In the lore segment, we dig into vengeful ghost folklore, the chilling Hawaiian legend of Tanaka the drowned ghost, and why What Lies Beneath (Michelle Pfeiffer, Harrison Ford) is still one of the great drowned-ghost movies.

The verdict: our favorite episode so far! The boys save the day (again), Dean gets another goodbye kiss (Sam gets nothing, again), and Lucas is miraculously trauma-free and talking. Victory!

"It must be hard with your sense of direction, never being able to find your way to a decent pickup line." – Andrea Barr

Your turn, hunters: Is this the best episode so far, or are you still Team Wendigo? And did Dean deserve that roast? Tell us in the Spotify comments, leave a rating and review on Apple Podcasts (it's how new hunters find us), or send us fan mail below. Bonus points for fandom fun facts we missed.

Sources:

• https://supernatural.fandom.com/wiki/Dead_In_The_Water
• http://tviv.org/Supernatural/Dead_in_the_Water
• https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vengeful_ghost
• https://obscurban-legend.fandom.com/wiki/Tanaka_the_Drowned_Ghost

Send us your review!

Support the show

Denim-wrapped Nightmares is a Supernatural rewatch podcast hosted by Berly and LA, breaking down every episode of the Winchester saga with lore deep-dives plus cast and crew interviews. Special thanks to David Fesliyan and Fesliyan Studios.

Subscribe, leave a review, and, if you choose to drink, please drink responsibly.

Join the hunt at linktr.ee/dwnpod where you can find links to socials and sign up for emails. Until next time, cheers!