Episode Details
Back to EpisodesE16| Investigative Detention: Was Leaning In, Lighting Up & Looking About Vehicle Justified?
Description
Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.
In this episode, Mike discusses the Ontario Court of Appeal decision R. v. Ahmed, 2022 ONCA 640 where police officers detained the occupants of a vehicle matching the description of one suspected of being involved in gunfire. When an officer leaned in the car through its open door and lit up its interior with a flashlight, he saw a firearm partially sticking out from under a seat. It turns out the gun was loaded and had an extended magazine containing 26 rounds of 9 mm ammunition. Was the search of the vehicle lawful as an incident to investigative detention?
Here are some quotes from the Ontario Court of Appeal that might help you answer this question:
Investigative Detention: “The requirements for a justifiable investigative detention are twofold: (1) police officers must have reasonable grounds to suspect that the specific person is implicated in the criminal activity under investigation; and (2) the decision to detain must be reasonable on an overall assessment of all circumstances.”
Protective Search: “The law is clear that the police have the power to briefly detain individuals for investigative purposes and to conduct a limited pat-down or safety search incident to that detention. When an officer has reasonable grounds to believe that their safety or that of others is at risk, the officer may engage in a protective pat-down search of the detained individual.”
Plain View: “There are four criteria to be applied: (i) The officer must be lawfully positioned relative to where the item is found; (ii) the nature of the evidence must be immediately apparent as constituting a criminal offence; (iii) the evidence must have been discovered inadvertently; and (iv) the item must be visible without any exploratory search.”
Thanks for listening! Feedback welcome at legalissuesinpolicing@gmail.com