Episode Details

The Story of Lorraine and "Anna"

In today's podcast, David and Rhonda interview Dr. Lorraine Wong, a board-certified clinical psychologist, and her patient, "Anna," who sought treatment recently for depression, anxiety, and self-image / self-esteem issues. But first, David and Rhonda answer a question submitted by Estafonia, a "public image consultant," who asks about the treatment of a woman who sees herself as "fat."

Estafonia wrote:

"Hi Dr. Burns,

"I am learning TEAM, CBT and implementing your techniques to help my clients change or improve their self-perception. In most cases, your techniques have been very effective. I am very grateful to you and I will happily join your list of fans!

"My question is this—What would be the best method to change someone's self-image? How can you help people change the idea that they are fat for example?

"I have a patient who can't defeat the thought, 'I am fat.' We tried the method called Examine the Evidence," and she has already found 20 people who see her as thin. So, the evidence clearly did not support her belief that she is fat. But this did not help.

"We also tried the method called Let's Define Terms, and we both concluded that she is not fat. But now she tells me, 'I know I am not fat, but I can't stop thinking about it.'

"We also did the Downward Arrow Technique to probe her deepest fears and Self-Defeating Beliefs, but that didn't seem to help, either, and she keeps ruminating about being fat. I would greatly appreciate your guidance on how to help her overcome that thought!

"Thanks in advance! Estefania"

Lorraine, Rhonda, David and Anna quickly diagnose the most likely cause of Estefania's stuckness—she is trying to "help" her patient without first melting away her patient's resistance. This is the cause of practically all therapeutic failure, and you're not really doing TEAM-CBT if you don't know how to eliminate the patient's resistance.

That's because most people are ambivalent about change. As the Jesuit mystic, Anthony DeMello, has said: "We yearn for change but cling to the familiar." Recognizing and modifying this inherent ambivalence is the heart of A = Paradoxical Agenda Setting, but you can also think of the A as standing for "Assessment of Resistance."

How could we melt away this woman's ambivalence / reluctance to stop bombarding herself with the message, "I'm fat"? It is important to realize that this self-critical thought, and, in fact, all of her negative thoughts and feelings have huge advantages for her, and also indicate some really beautiful and awesome things about her and her core values.

For example, telling herself "I'm fat" may motivate her to diet, to exercise, and to make extra sure that she doesn't get complacent and gain a tremendous amount of weight. In addition, the thought, "I'm fat," shows that she has high standards, and her high standards have probably motivated her success in many areas of her life. For example, she probably works really hard to stay in good health and in good physical condition.

The thought, "I'm fat," also shows that she's humble, and on and on and on. And that's just one negative thought. But this woman probably has many negative thoughts and feelings, like anxiety, shame, inferiority and depression, and they ALL have tremendous advantages, and they ALL reveal what is beautiful and awesome about her and her core values.

In addition, the thought may be protecting this patient from things she fears, like intimacy. As long as she tells herself, "I'm fat," she does have to risk trying to get close, or having sex, or risking rejection. So the thought, in a way, is a form of self-love and self-protection.

Once Estafonia and her patient list all these positives, Estafonia could ask her patient, "Given all these advantages and positive qualities, maybe it wouldn't