Podcast Episodes
Back to SearchJob Corps to Death Row: The Christa Pike Case
Season 4 Episode 12
Send us Fan Mail
In 1995, 18-year-old Christa Pike was enrolled in Job Corps in Knoxville, Tennessee—a program meant to help young people build a futu…
2 hours ago
The Devil in the Details: A Killer at Thirteen
Season 4 Episode 11
Send us Fan Mail
What happens when the person you should be safest with becomes the person you never saw coming?
In 2007, thirteen-year-old Paris Benne…
2 weeks ago
GOOD BOY, BAD ALIBI: THE SON OF SAM MURDERS
Season 4 Episode 10
Send us Fan Mail
New York City, 1976.
A killer is stalking the streets after dark, seemingly choosing his victims at random and leaving an entire city …
3 weeks ago
Holy Hell: The Murder of Sister Margaret Ann Pahl
Season 4 Episode 9
Send us Fan Mail
Easter weekend, 1980. A Catholic nun walks into a chapel to prepare for Easter Sunday—and never makes it home.
Sister Margaret Ann Pah…
4 weeks ago
Barrels, Bodies & Bob Evans
Season 4 Episode 8
Send us Fan Mail
This week on Thick Thighs and Murder Vibes, we’re diving into the Bear Brook murders—a case that starts with a barrel, gets progressi…
1 month ago
Hinterkaifeck: A Stranger in the Shadows
Send us Fan Mail
This week, things are looking a little different around here because Terra has company. Shaq is stepping into the guest-host seat, an…
1 month, 2 weeks ago
The Wrong Way Home: The Diane Schuler Mystery
Season 4 Episode 6
Send us Fan Mail
In 2009, a horrific crash on the Taconic State Parkway left eight people dead and raised a question that still sparks debate today: h…
1 month, 3 weeks ago
Lights, Camera, Murder: The Guy Who Thought He Was Dexter
Season 4 Episode 5
Send us Fan Mail
What happens when a wannabe filmmaker becomes a little too obsessed with the idea of being a fictional serial killer?
Mark Twitchell w…
2 months, 1 week ago
Episode 2: Missy Bevers, Part 2 | Everybody Had Questions. Nobody Had Answers.
Season 4 Episode 4
Send us Fan Mail
Last week, we walked through the chilling timeline, the haunting church surveillance footage, and the investigation that left more qu…
2 months, 2 weeks ago
The Unsolved Murder of Missy Bevers | Part 1: Who the Hell Was in That Tactical Gear?
Season 4 Episode 3
Send us Fan Mail
What was supposed to be an early morning fitness class turned into one of the most baffling unsolved murders in true crime history.
In…
2 months, 3 weeks ago